You are currently viewing When “we need more sales” is the wrong diagnosis

When “we need more sales” is the wrong diagnosis

  • Reading time:5 mins read

Your sales team delivers the extra orders you asked for. Three months later, profit is down, cash is tighter and your best customers are waiting longer. Did the team fail — or did it deliver exactly what the business asked for?

“We need more sales” is an understandable response to slowing growth. Who doesn’t want more sales? But before raising targets, increasing discounts or opening another market, I would ask: 

Do we understand what is holding growth back — and what more sales would actually do to the business?

The discount looks small. The required volume is not.

Take a product selling for €100, with variable costs of €70. Each unit contributes €30 towards fixed costs and profit. A 10% discount brings the price to €90 and the contribution to €20. You now need 50% more units to generate the same total contribution, assuming unchanged variable cost per unit and no additional fixed costs. Before approving the discount, have we established where those extra orders will come from — and whether we can fulfil them economically?

In a case described by McKinsey in 2024, an IT distributor tested lower prices across 15 large accounts for two months. The additional volume did not compensate for the value lost through discounting.[1] A discount may be justified. “It will help us sell more” is only half the calculation.

A busy factory can still be making the wrong things.

Imagine a promotion generating small orders across ten slow-moving product variants. Production keeps switching between them. Meanwhile, a core product runs short. The promotion meets its volume target. Yet the business may have sacrificed better orders, incurred extra changeover costs and disappointed repeat customers.

This is an illustration, but the mechanism is documented: McKinsey describes how smaller production runs can increase changeovers, idle time and expenses while weakening service levels.[3] Economies of scale depend on how volume moves through the operation. More units spread across more complexity may deliver very little scale. A low-volume product can still deserve its place. Its margin, strategic role and demands on capacity need to justify that place.

Your distributor’s warehouse is not the consumer.

Another shipment can improve this month’s revenue while making next month’s problem bigger. If distributor stock rises without corresponding sell-out, have we created demand or brought forward an order?

Which products are reaching stores? Are they available on the shelf when shoppers want them? Which are moving, and which are waiting? Without these answers, “the distributor needs to sell harder” remains an assumption.

Marketing needs a seat at this table.

Marketing belongs in this diagnosis alongside sales, finance and operations.

Availability matters. So does giving people a reason to choose us. Does our brand still address a relevant need? What triggers the purchase: a recognisable pack, a clear benefit, trust, convenience, price? And when did we last test that understanding?

In NIQ’s survey of online consumers across 25 countries, published in 2025, 68% considered private labels good alternatives to name brands.[2] Familiarity alone does not guarantee preference. Sales, marketing and operations need to connect what shoppers value, what we promise and what we actually deliver. A stronger campaign cannot resolve repeated stockouts. Better distribution cannot make an irrelevant offer compelling.

Management needs the same scrutiny. When evidence challenges our positioning or priorities, do we investigate — or defend the decisions we made?

Before the next sales push, answer five questions.

I would bring sales, marketing, finance and operations together to establish:

  • Where has performance changed? Separate price, volume and mix by product, customer, channel and market.
  • Which orders are worth growing? Check contribution after discounts, costs to serve and use of scarce capacity.
  • What happens after shipment? Examine sell-out, partner stock, availability and repeat orders.
  • Why do people choose us? Compare our beliefs with shopper feedback, observation and focused tests.
  • What should change first? Select one supported diagnosis, assign an owner and measure the response.

Now return to that sales team delivering its target. If the extra orders depend on deeper discounts, congest production and fill a distributor’s warehouse, the team may have executed the instruction perfectly. Management may have set a target that rewards the very behaviour making the business weaker.

The next decision could be to stop one promotion, protect capacity for core products or repair replenishment before chasing new listings. It could also be to invest in selling more — once the evidence supports it. AI can help us analyse the numbers faster. It cannot make an unexamined target a sound decision.

Before your next sales push, let’s examine one area where the numbers do not add up. Contact me with the product, customer, channel or market that concerns you, and what has changed. We can use that as the starting point for a focused conversation about what to investigate first.

Sources and further reading

[1] McKinsey & Company (2024). How to navigate pricing during disinflationary times.

[2] NielsenIQ (2025). Finding Harmony on the Shelf: 2025 Global Outlook on Private Label & Branded Products.

[3] McKinsey & Company (2020). Harnessing the power of simplicity in a complex consumer-product environment.

The pricing calculation and factory scenario are illustrative, not reported client cases.